Sam Sloat Coins Reviews & Complaints: Scam or Reputable?

Sam Sloat Coins
Google: 4.5/5
Trustpilot: N/a

Sam Sloat Coins, a numismatic company located in Westport, Connecticut, specializes in various aspects of coin trading and collection. Offering services in the purchase and evaluation of rare coins, gold and silver bullion, currency, and jewelry, they have established a reputation for their expertise and variety of offerings. The company has been operational since 1961, making it one of the oldest and largest coin shops in New England. They are noted for their reliability and diverse product range. Sam Sloat Coins has an average rating of 4.5/5 on Focus on the User.

Jump To:

Featured Reviews

Top Review

H Hawk
5 stars

"Feel fortunate to have found Sam Sloat coins. From the first phone call through the sale of a collection of coins my interactions with Andrew, Christine and Bob was professional..."

Read Reviews

Top Complaint

Stacy L
1 star

"Sam Sloat buys stolen items and lies about it they make money and the victim loses. I wish I could have pressed charges against Sam Sloat. My ex friend who stole my items..."

Read Complaints

What is Sam Sloat Coins?

Founded in 1961, Sam Sloat Coins, Inc. has grown into a prominent numismatic entity in New England. Not just limited to coins, their inventory extends to U.S., world, and ancient coins, paper money, bullion silver, gold and platinum, tokens, and medals. Their expertise also covers areas such as vintage sports cards and memorabilia, celebrity and sports autographs, political campaign and advertising pinbacks, estate and diamond jewelry, and sterling silver flatware and hollow ware. With over 60 years of experience, Sam Sloat Coins operates both a physical storefront and an online presence, including a significant eBay store where they are recognized as top-rated sellers with outstanding customer service. Their physical store, spanning 1,200 square feet, allows for an extensive display of their varied collection.

Sam Sloat Coins Ratings

Sam Sloat Coins Reputation

Focus on the User Review
Focus on the User
4.5/5 stars
39 reviews (Aggregated)
Google Reviews
Google Reviews
4.5/5 stars
39 reviews
BBB Reviews
N/a reviews
Trustpilot Reviews
N/a stars
N/a reviews

Exclusive Offer: FREE Coin When Opening Gold IRA

FotU Coin
Sam Sloat Coins Reviews

Top Sam Sloat Coins Reviews

5 starsFeatured

"Feel fortunate to have found Sam Sloat coins. From the first phone call through the sale of a collection of coins my interactions with Andrew, Christine and Bob was professional, friendly and easy. They have a great knowledge of the business and treat you kindly, fairly and professionally. Highly recommend!"

H Hawk
5 stars
5 starsFeatured

"I was very pleased with my visit to this shop. I bought in coins to sell and was very comfortable with the whole experience. I worked with Christine and she was very nice and talked me through the process and what they look for. I left feeling comfortable that I chose the right place."

Barbara D
5 stars
5 starsFeatured

"I brought in a sterling silver bar that my stepfather had given me one year ago, looking to sell it.I had done my research online and knew its approximate value, and was pleased when the sales clerk offered me a fair price.The shop is clean, well-organized and, I would imagine, a real treasure trove for collectors.My transaction took just a few minutes, but my daughter and I stayed for another ten minutes to have a nice conversation with the sales clerk, who made us feel right at home.I would recommend Sam Sloat Coins to collectors and to non-collectors, like me, who want a fair price for their valuables."

Cynthia B
5 stars
Sam Sloat Coins Complaints

Worst Sam Sloat Coins Complaints

1 starFeatured

"Sam Sloat buys stolen items and lies about it they make money and the victim loses. I wish I could have pressed charges against Sam Sloat. My ex friend who stole my items went back to Sam Sloat 7 different days you think they would have caught on. I found a Sam Sloat receipt that my ex friend dropped and both me and my husband separately went to Sam Sloat to ask them about the items. They denied ever seeing or purchasing our items. I had pics and appraisals. Police got involved. Detectives went to Sam Sloat obtained videos of the person selling them jewelry and receipts. My ex friend was found guilty on Felony Larceny charges. I never got any items back from Sam Sloat."

Stacy L
1 star
1 starFeatured

"Awful, I was in the store around 1:00 and realized I had coins to sell that cost more, I went home Westport to Southport and retrieved the coins. I returned at 1:58, yes they close at 2:00 so I was cutting it close however there was still customers in the store. So I opened the door and got an earful from the manager. I work as someone who collects bills and have never been treated so poorly. I have no words, just..... just wow."

Charles C
1 star

Is Sam Sloat Coins a Scam?

Sam Sloat Coins is not a scam. Established in 1961, this reputable company has a longstanding history in the numismatic field, marked by reliability and expertise. Their positive rating of 4.5/5 by Focus on the User further reinforces their legitimacy and commitment to customer satisfaction.

Sam Sloat Coins Pros and Cons


  • Diverse Inventory: Offers a wide range of products including rare coins, bullion, memorabilia, and jewelry.
  • Reputation and Experience: Over 60 years in business, known for reliability and expertise.


  • Limited Online Information: Details about specific services and products may be less accessible online.
  • Physical Store Dependent: Customers outside of Connecticut might have limited access to their full range of services and products.

Sam Sloat Coins Services and Products

Sam Sloat Coins provides a broad spectrum of services and products catering to numismatists and collectors. Their offerings include:

  • Rare Coins: Specializing in U.S., world, and ancient coins.
  • Bullion: Trading in gold, silver, and platinum bullion.
  • Currency: Dealing with various types of paper money.
  • Memorabilia: Offering vintage sports cards, celebrity and sports autographs, and political campaign pinbacks.
  • Jewelry and Silverware: Estate and diamond jewelry, sterling silver flatware and hollow ware.

Sam Sloat Coins FAQ

Is Sam Sloat Coins a reputable company?

Yes, with over 60 years of experience and a solid reputation in New England.

How long has Sam Sloat Coins been in business?

Since 1961.

How does Sam Sloat Coins work?

They buy, sell, and evaluate rare coins, bullion, currency, memorabilia, jewelry, and silverware, serving both in-store and online customers.

Before Investing With Sam Sloat Coins

Consider acquiring . This resource can help you make informed decisions about investing in precious metals.

Sam Sloat Coins Homepage

Contact Sam Sloat Coins

  • Address: 1767 Post Rd E, Westport, CT 06880-5606
  • Phone: (203) 226-4279
  • Founded: 1961
  • Alternative Name:
  • Business Contacts:
    • Bob Walter, President
    • Christine Mather, Office Manager
  • Category: Numismatic Company
Social MediaBusiness Hours
  • Saturday - 10AM–2PM
  • Sunday - Closed
  • Monday - Closed
  • Tuesday - 10AM–4PM
  • Wednesday - 10AM–4PM
  • Thursday - 10AM–4PM
  • Friday - 10AM–4PM
Sam Sloat Coins Address

Sam Sloat Coins Alternatives

American Rarities Review

American Rarities | 3/5 Rating

American Rarities is known for its expertise in rare coins and bullion, providing free evaluations and personalized service for collectors looking to buy, sell, or appraise their collections.
Bunker Hill Rare Coin Review

Bunker Hill Rare Coin | 3/5 Rating

Bunker Hill Rare Coin focuses on high-quality rare coins and offers personalized services, including appraisals, acquisitions, and sales to serious collectors and investors.
Liberty Coin Review

Liberty Coin | 3/5 Rating

Liberty Coin offers a wide selection of coins, precious metals, and collectibles, catering to both novice and experienced collectors with a focus on customer education and satisfaction. Review | 3/5 Rating is a prominent online retailer of coins and collectibles, specializing in government-issued coins from around the world, including modern and historical pieces.
Modern Coin Mart Review

Modern Coin Mart | 3/5 Rating

Modern Coin Mart stands out for its extensive selection of modern coins and bullion products, catering to collectors interested in the latest releases and innovative coin designs.
NGC Review

Numismatic Guaranty Corporation (NGC) | 1.9/5 Rating

Numismatic Guaranty Corporation (NGC) is a leading third-party grading service for coins, tokens, and medals, offering grading, conservation, and encapsulation services to enhance and certify their value and authenticity.
PCGS Review

Professional Coin Grading Service (PCGS) | 1.2/5 Rating

Professional Coin Grading Service (PCGS) is a highly respected coin grading company, known for its standard-setting grading services and encapsulation techniques that help preserve and authenticate coins.
ANACS Review

ANACS (American Numismatic Association Certification Service) | 1/5 Rating

ANACS (American Numismatic Association Certification Service), as the oldest coin authentication and grading service in the U.S., offers expert grading and authentication services to collectors and dealers.

Discover How to Effortlessly Rollover Gold Into Your IRA

Our free eBook covers everything you need to know before you start diverisfying your retirement with precious metals like gold or silver.

Was this resource helpful? Share it with your friends!

Disclaimer: Content on this website is not intended to be used as financial advice. It is not to be used as a recommendation to buy, sell, or trade an asset that requires a licensed broker. Consult a financial advisor.

Speak With An Expert, Learn More About Diversifying IRA With Gold