American Rarities Reviews & Complaints: Scam or Reputable?

American Rarities
Google: 1/5
BBB: 4.74/5 A+
Trustpilot: N/a

American Rarities is a numismatic company based in Boulder, Colorado. The company, established in 1995, specializes in purchasing and appraising rare coins, gold and silver bullion, and U.S. paper currency. It operates nationwide, with multiple locations offering these services. The company's reputation is built on providing accurate valuations and fair market prices for rare coins and precious metals. American Rarities has a 3/5 rating on Focus on the User.

Jump To:

Featured Reviews

Top Review

M Mc
5 stars

"My experience with AR was smooth, professional but most of all friendly. The buyer, David, was helpful, knowledgable and patient. Payment was really fast and easy..."

Read Reviews

Top Complaint

Kenzy L
1 star

"Found this place on Google, it said they were open from 9am to 9pm I thought I would check it out, I drove 45 minutes to come out and can't find it. So I call for 30 minutes with..."

Read Complaints

What is American Rarities?

American Rarities, founded in 1995 and incorporated in 1998, is a professional rare coin dealer. For over 25 years, it has served coin collectors across the United States. The company is known for purchasing American and foreign rare coins, U.S. paper currency, and bullion material. They also provide free appraisals for all collections examined for purchase. The company's reputation in the numismatic field is bolstered by its team of experts, many of whom have attended ANA grading and authentication courses. Warren Zivi, the president and founder, leads the company, which is accredited by the Better Business Bureau since 2004.

American Rarities Ratings

American Rarities Reputation

Focus on the User Review
Focus on the User
3/5 stars
20 reviews (Aggregated)
Google Reviews
Google Reviews
1/5 stars
1 review
BBB Reviews
4.74/5 stars A+
19 reviews
Trustpilot Reviews
N/a stars
N/a reviews

Exclusive Offer: FREE Coin When Opening Gold IRA

FotU Coin
American Rarities Reviews

Top American Rarities Reviews

5 starsFeatured

"My experience with AR was smooth, professional but most of all friendly. The buyer, David, was helpful, knowledgable and patient. Payment was really fast and easy.The whole experience was SMOOTH!Will definitely do business with American Rarities again."

M Mc
5 stars
5 starsFeatured

"A friend had the coin collection of her husband. He had passed away 27 years ago and she wanted to cash the collection in. We contacted American Rarities and the business was quickly transacted. My husband is a collector and he knew enough to tell that we were getting a fair price for them. It was a great experience and I happily recommend the company. It was a win-win scenario and all are happy with the outcome."

Jacque M
5 stars
5 starsFeatured

"Fantastic staff and authentic professional services. Whether you've come into a collection from a relative/heirlooms or are a competitive buyer and seller, American Rarities delivers the best pricing and service in the industry. Very happy with my appraisal/sale, netted additional once reviewed by the appraiser!"

John M
5 stars
American Rarities Complaints

Worst American Rarities Complaints

1 starFeatured

"Found this place on Google, it said they were open from 9am to 9pm I thought I would check it out, I drove 45 minutes to come out and can't find it. So I call for 30 minutes with no answer, finally I leave a semi rude voicemail, and they answered on my next call, only to tell me they don't "work like that" and I have to make an appointment to see their store.... maybe change the '9am to 9pm' hours to 'appointment only' and save some people the trouble, or just pick up the damn phone!"

Kenzy L
1 star
1 starFeatured

"American Rarities had started out with much promise for receiving an appraisal for currency and a possible sell. Since I had 20 pictures there was difficulty in sending the pictures off because American Rarities website accommodates only 5 pictures. Of course I could have provided a list but I thought the pictures would best demonstrate what had to offer. On the website it does say if you have additional pictures or money list please send an email but with 20 total pictures the data was too much to send all 20 pictures. Not sure if they had a Drop Box account so a picture link was created, sent and confirmed receipt. However after repeated calls a week had gone by when finally a quote came back for the original 5 pieces and not the 20 pieces. When asked about the 20 pieces I was told they didn't receive 20 pieces. Later they did confirm the picture link but with so much time passing the link was no longer valid.Needless to say a very difficult experience. Good luck to all who wish to use American Rarities."

Bob F
1 star

Is American Rarities a Scam?

American Rarities is not a scam. The company has been in business since 1995, displaying longevity and stability in the numismatic industry. Its BBB accreditation since 2004 and the expertise of its staff further reinforce its legitimacy. The rating by Focus on the User reflects its standing in the market.

American Rarities Pros and Cons


  • Accreditation: American Rarities is accredited by the BBB, reflecting its commitment to customer satisfaction and business integrity.
  • Expertise: With nearly three decades of experience, the company's expert team offers precise coin valuations and appraisals.


  • Limited Communication Options: The absence of live chat support restricts efficient customer communication, leading to slower response times.
  • Mixed Customer Reviews: Despite high BBB ratings, some negative reviews on Yelp question the company's overall credibility.

American Rarities Services and Products

American Rarities offers a range of services and products:

  • Rare Coin Purchase: They buy various types of rare coins, both American and foreign.
  • Paper Currency Purchase: U.S. paper currency is also purchased.
  • Bullion Trading: The company deals in gold and silver bullion coins and bars.
  • Free Appraisals: They provide free appraisals for coin collections.

American Rarities FAQ

Is American Rarities a reputable company?

Yes, with BBB accreditation and decades of experience, American Rarities is considered reputable in its field.

How long has American Rarities been in business?

American Rarities was founded in 1995.

Who is the owner of American Rarities?

The company is owned by Warren Zivi, its founder and president.

How does American Rarities work?

American Rarities operates by purchasing rare coins, paper currency, and bullion, offering free appraisals, and conducting transactions through various locations across the U.S.

Before Investing With American Rarities

It's advisable to consider obtaining to make informed decisions about investments in precious metals. This guide can help in understanding the nuances of investing with companies like American Rarities.

American Rarities Homepage

Contact American Rarities

  • Address: Boulder, CO 80301-4008
  • Phone: (800) 622-5680
  • Founded: 1995
  • Alternative Name:
  • Business Contacts:
    • Warren Zivi, President and Founder
    • Sharon B. Zivi, Member
  • Category: Numismatic Grading Company
Social MediaBusiness Hours
  • Saturday - 9AM–2PM
  • Sunday - Closed
  • Monday - 9AM–5PM
  • Tuesday - 9AM–5PM
  • Wednesday - 9AM–5PM
  • Thursday - 9AM–5PM
  • Friday - 9AM–3PM
American Rarities Address

American Rarities Alternatives

Sam Sloat Coins | 4.5/5 Rating

Sam Sloat Coins specializes in rare coins, paper currency, and precious metals, offering expert appraisal services and a diverse inventory for collectors and investors.
Bunker Hill Rare Coin Review

Bunker Hill Rare Coin | 3/5 Rating

Bunker Hill Rare Coin focuses on high-quality rare coins and offers personalized services, including appraisals, acquisitions, and sales to serious collectors and investors.
Liberty Coin Review

Liberty Coin | 3/5 Rating

Liberty Coin offers a wide selection of coins, precious metals, and collectibles, catering to both novice and experienced collectors with a focus on customer education and satisfaction. Review | 3/5 Rating is a prominent online retailer of coins and collectibles, specializing in government-issued coins from around the world, including modern and historical pieces.
Modern Coin Mart Review

Modern Coin Mart | 3/5 Rating

Modern Coin Mart stands out for its extensive selection of modern coins and bullion products, catering to collectors interested in the latest releases and innovative coin designs.
NGC Review

Numismatic Guaranty Corporation (NGC) | 1.9/5 Rating

Numismatic Guaranty Corporation (NGC) is a leading third-party grading service for coins, tokens, and medals, offering grading, conservation, and encapsulation services to enhance and certify their value and authenticity.
PCGS Review

Professional Coin Grading Service (PCGS) | 1.2/5 Rating

Professional Coin Grading Service (PCGS) is a highly respected coin grading company, known for its standard-setting grading services and encapsulation techniques that help preserve and authenticate coins.
ANACS Review

ANACS (American Numismatic Association Certification Service) | 1/5 Rating

ANACS (American Numismatic Association Certification Service), as the oldest coin authentication and grading service in the U.S., offers expert grading and authentication services to collectors and dealers.

Discover How to Effortlessly Rollover Gold Into Your IRA

Our free eBook covers everything you need to know before you start diverisfying your retirement with precious metals like gold or silver.

Was this resource helpful? Share it with your friends!

Disclaimer: Content on this website is not intended to be used as financial advice. It is not to be used as a recommendation to buy, sell, or trade an asset that requires a licensed broker. Consult a financial advisor.

Speak With An Expert, Learn More About Diversifying IRA With Gold